The story: Italian journalist Cecilia Sala has returned to Rome after three weeks in Iranian custody. Having been detained in Tehran shortly after the arrest of an Iranian engineer in Milan upon a US warrant, observers speculate that a tit-for-tat operation is at play. The freeing of Sala could therefore indicate a possible prisoner swap. It also suggests that Iran seeks to resolve the matter before US President-elect Donald Trump returns to the White House later this month.

The coverage: The office of Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said in a Jan. 8 statement that Sala had been freed “thanks to intense work involving diplomatic and intelligence channels.”

• Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani also celebrated the development on Twitter/X, hailing “diplomacy and teamwork.”
  
  
• Italian media on Jan. 8 released images of Sala arriving in Rome. Reports indicate she was held in solitary confinement at Tehran's Evin Prison.

29-year-old Sala, a newspaper journalist and podcaster, was arrested in Iran on Dec. 19 for allegedly "violating the Islamic Republic's laws." Days earlier, an Iranian engineer was detained in Italy upon a request by US authorities for allegedly transferring drone technology to Iran.

• Mohammad Abedini was arrested by Italian authorities on Dec. 16 under a US warrant for alleged sanctions violations. Abedini is accused of supplying drone parts that, according to Washington, were used in a 2024 attack that killed three US service members in Jordan.
  
  
• Abedini was denied conditional release earlier in January. A court hearing has been scheduled for Jan. 15 to consider his request for transfer to house arrest.

The two arrests led to diplomatic tensions between Iran and Italy.

• In reciprocal moves, Rome and Tehran summoned the Iranian and Italian ambassadors on Jan. 2 and Jan. 3 respectively. Iran condemned Abedini's arrest as “politically motivated and hostile” and described it as “hostage-taking.”
  
  
• While Italy's foreign ministry did not address potential links between Sala and Abedini's cases, a US State Department spokesperson suggested that the Italian journalist was used by Tehran as "political leverage."

Some commentators have floated the possibility that Trump may directly or indirectly have been involved in Sala’s release.

• Mehdi Nakhl-Ahmadi, a Turin-based Iranian journalist, suggested that Tehran freed Sala to curry favor with Meloni, who has a good relationship with the US president-elect.
  
  
• Rome-based Iranian pundit Shahid Modares speculated that Trump may have encouraged Meloni during their meeting on Jan. 5 in Florida to swap Abedini for Sala because he “did not want it to become a challenge during his presidency.”

The context/analysis: Iran has long been accused by western governments and human rights advocates of engaging in “hostage diplomacy” to secure concessions or the release of Iranians who have been detained overseas.

• In controversial comments, Mohsen Rafiqdoost, a former Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) commander, once boasted about Iran having taken “hostages from world powers.”
  
  
• Hardline media later slammed the ex-IRGC commander for referring to foreign prisoners as “hostages.”

Over the past two years, Iran has released several high-profile foreign and dual nationals in exchange for detained Iranian citizens and funds frozen abroad.

• Iran in June 2024 secured the release of former judiciary official Hamid Nouri, who had been sentenced to serve a life term in a Swedish prison. In exchange, Tehran freed Swedish citizens Johan Floderus and Saeed Azizi.
  
  
• In Sept. 2023, Iran released several US citizens—including Iranian-American businessman Siamak Namazi—in exchange for Washington freeing five Iranian nationals and the release of 5.5B EUR of Iranian funds that had been frozen in South Korea.
  
  
• In May 2023, Iran released Belgian aid worker Olivier Vandecasteele, who had been sentenced to 40 years in prison and 74 lashes for alleged espionage. In exchange, Belgian authorities freed Iranian diplomat Assadollah Assadi, who was serving a 20-year sentence for allegedly plotting a bomb attack on a rally of the exiled opposition group Mojahedin-e Khalq (MEK) in France.

The future: Iran's continued detention of foreign and Iranian dual nationals as supposed leverage has faced condemnation from western nations and rights groups, damaging its global image and discouraging tourism.

• Despite the backlash, Iran’s detentions have secured the release of citizens often arrested in third countries due to alleged violations of US sanctions. Tehran has also managed to access frozen assets abroad, albeit only for nonsanctionable trade. These dynamics have raised concerns that the Islamic Republic may be encouraged to pursue the same path, and such criticisms may be reignited if Abedini is released soon.
  
  
• However, Tehran may also be hoping that by releasing Sala it will score goodwill with Meloni. Given her background and Italy’s generally stable relations with Iran, the Italian prime minister could be in a unique position to help press for mediation between Iran and the incoming Trump administration.

Please support our work

Only €10 a month (or €100 a year) would allow us to keep delivering original coverage.

Only €10 a month (or €100 a year) would keep us going.

Recurring tipOne-off tip

Supported payment methods: